Going beyond technocratic and democratic principles: Stakeholder acceptance of instruments in Swiss energy policy

Kammermann, Lorenz; Ingold, Karin (2019). Going beyond technocratic and democratic principles: Stakeholder acceptance of instruments in Swiss energy policy. Policy sciences, 52(1), pp. 43-65. Springer 10.1007/s11077-018-9341-5

Preview	Text KammermannIngold_2018_PolicySciences.pdf - Accepted Version Available under License Publisher holds Copyright. Download (386kB) | Preview
Preview	Text Kammermann-Ingold2018_Article_GoingBeyondTechnocraticAndDemo.pdf - Published Version Available under License Publisher holds Copyright. Download (940kB) | Preview

This paper is about stakeholders’ acceptance regarding regulatory instruments in energy
policy. We expect that today’s introduced instruments not only correspond most to technocratic
principles and what elected officials prefer, but that they correlate with the preferences
of a wider number of public and private actors in policymaking. We therefore
compare the already introduced policy instruments to instrument preferences of the public
administration, elected officials, but also NGOs and utilities. In doing so, we contribute to
the question of whether or not the instruments already introduced today correspond to technocratic or democratic principles, or to the preferences of the larger governance arrangement involving other public and private actors. We compare three cantons in Switzerland and gather data through a systematic literature review, expert interviews, and surveys. The comparison of the data suggest that the currently selected policy instruments correspond to
technocratic principles, but that they also and often correspond to the preferences of public
and private actors. More concretely, whereas in one canton, NGO preferences align with
the introduced instruments, in another canton, this is the case for utilities. In the third canton, all different actor types display similar preferences very much in accordance with the currently employed instrument mix. We thus conclude that depending on the region, different principles and preferences are reflected in the current policy mix.

Interest & Impact

Downloads

234 since deposited on 07 Dec 2018
62 in the past 12 months

Citations

5 Citations in Web of Science ®
6 Citations in Scopus

Search

in Google Scholar™

Services

Actions (login required)

Edit item

Actions (login required)

Edit item