What about Happiness? A Critical Narrative Review with Implications for Medical Education.

Schwitz, Fabienne; Torti, Jacqueline; Lingard, Lorelei (2023). What about Happiness? A Critical Narrative Review with Implications for Medical Education. Perspectives on medical education, 12(1), pp. 208-217. Ubiquity Press 10.5334/pme.856

Preview

Text 647f0ce92aa68.pdf - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons: Attribution (CC-BY). Download (996kB) | Preview

INTRODUCTION

Despite abundant scholarship and improvement initiatives, the problem of physician wellbeing persists. One reason might be conceptual: the idea of 'happiness' is rare in this work. To explore how it might influence the conversation about physician wellbeing in medical education, we conducted a critical narrative review asking: 'How does happiness feature in the medical education literature on physician wellbeing at work?' and 'How is happiness conceptualized outside medicine?'

METHODS

Following current methodological standards for critical narrative review as well as the Scale for the Assessment of Narrative Review Articles, we conducted a structured search in health research, humanities and social sciences, a grey literature search, and consultation with experts. After screening and selection, content analysis was performed.

RESULTS

Of 401 identified records, 23 were included. Concepts of happiness from the fields of psychology (flow, synthetic happiness, mindfulness, flourishing), organizational behaviour (job satisfaction, happy-productive worker thesis, engagement), economics (happiness industry, status treadmill), and sociology (contentment, tyranny of positivity, coercive happiness) were identified. The medical education records exclusively drew on psychological concepts of happiness.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

This critical narrative review introduces a variety of conceptualizations of happiness from diverse disciplinary origins. Only four medical education papers were identified, all drawing from positive psychology which orients us to treat happiness as individual, objective, and necessarily good. This may constrain both our understanding of the problem of physician wellbeing and our imagined solutions. Organizational, economical and sociological conceptualizations of happiness can usefully expand the conversation about physician wellbeing at work.

Interest & Impact

Downloads

48 since deposited on 12 Jun 2023
44 in the past 12 months

Citations

5 Citations in Web of Science ®
6 Citations in Scopus

Search

in Google Scholar™

Services

Actions (login required)

Edit item

Actions (login required)

Edit item