Paternalism, Placebos, and Informed Consent in Psychotherapy

Blease, Charlotte; Trachsel, Manuel; grosse Holtforth, Martin (2016). Paternalism, Placebos, and Informed Consent in Psychotherapy. Verhaltenstherapie, 26(1), pp. 22-30. Karger 10.1159/000442928

Preview

Text 442928.pdf - Published Version Available under License Publisher holds Copyright. Download (630kB) | Preview

From a legal as well as ethical point of view, healthcare professionals are nowadays obliged to obtain informed consent (IC) of patients. Consequently, paternalism is eschewed in most ethical codes of practice and IC. But what should IC mean in psychotherapy? With respect to this question, the claim that psychotherapy may be a placebo may raise grave concerns for its ethical practice. Indeed, almost since the inception of psychotherapy some scholars have claimed that psychotherapy is a sham and/or it may work as a placebo. However, we argue that in clinical biomedicine there is still much conceptual confusion about the terms ‘placebo’ and ‘placebo effect’; moreover, we contend that the term ‘placebo’, when applied to psychotherapy, may invite more questions than it can easily resolve. Nonetheless, we assert that the core moral debate about clinical placebos raises important themes that are transferable to a psychotherapy context: namely: Are therapists providing adequate information to patients about how psychotherapy works? In light of ongoing empirical research into psychotherapy we argue that therapists may be failing to mention key features (so-called common factors) that are relevant to the process of therapeutic change. We assert that current psychotherapy practice appears to exhibit misplaced paternalism in failing to provide patients with this information. We conclude that any justification for paternalism on the grounds of beneficence is unfounded and that adequate disclosure policies are likely to enhance rather than undermine the therapeutic process.

Interest & Impact

Downloads

372 since deposited on 09 Feb 2017
34 in the past 12 months

Citations

5 Citations in Web of Science ®
6 Citations in Scopus

Search

in Google Scholar™

Services

Actions (login required)

Edit item

Actions (login required)

Edit item