(Ab)Using Regression for Data Adjustment

Dümbgen, Lutz (2016). (Ab)Using Regression for Data Adjustment (Technical report 78). Bern: IMSV, University of Bern

Preview

Text AdjustmentsRegression.pdf - Published Version Available under License BORIS Standard License. Download (681kB) | Preview

In various economic applications, people want to compare $n$ units with respect to certain quantities Y₁, Y₂, ..., Yn measuring their performance. The latter, however, is often influenced by certain factors which are beyond control of the units, and one would like to extract an adjusted performance from the data. Specifically, let Xi ⋲ X summarize the factors of the i-th unit. Then one could think of a model equation Yi = fo(Xi) + ɛi with a regression function fo : X → R describing the unavoidable influence of the factors Xi and ɛi being the adjusted performance of the i-th unit. Now a common proposal is to estimate fo via regression methods by a function ^f depending on the current data (Xi,Yi), possibly augmented by additional past data, and to use the residuals ^ɛi := Yi - ^f(Xi) as surrogates for the adjusted performances ɛi. In the present report we discuss this approach, its potential pitfalls and (mis)interpretation. In particular, an unavoidable property of the residuals ^ɛi$ is that they measure only parts of the adjusted performance while the remaining parts get hidden in the estimated function ^f. Possible alternatives are mentioned briefly.

Interest & Impact

Downloads

314 since deposited on 05 Sep 2016
15 in the past 12 months

Citations

5 Citations in Web of Science ®
6 Citations in Scopus

Search

in Google Scholar™

Services

Actions (login required)

Edit item

Actions (login required)

Edit item