Blood and lymphatic vessel invasion in pT1 colorectal cancer: an international concordance study

Kojima, Motohiro; Puppa, Giacomo; Kirsch, Richard; Basturk, Olca; Frankel, Wendy L; Vieth, Michael; Lugli, Alessandro; Sheahan, Kieran; Yeh, Matthew; Lauwers, Greg Y; Risio, Mauro; Shimazaki, Hideyuki; Iwaya, Keiichi; Kage, Masayoshi; Akiba, Jun; Ohkura, Yasuo; Horiguchi, Shinichiro; Shomori, Kohei; Kushima, Ryoji; Nomura, Shogo; ... (2015). Blood and lymphatic vessel invasion in pT1 colorectal cancer: an international concordance study. Journal of clinical pathology, 68(8), pp. 628-632. BMJ Publishing Group 10.1136/jclinpath-2014-202805

Text J Clin Pathol-2015-Kojima-jclinpath-2014-202805.pdf - Published Version Restricted to registered users only Available under License Publisher holds Copyright. Download (175kB) | Request a copy

AIM

This study was performed to evaluate the concordance in pathological assessments of blood and lymphatic vessel invasion (BLI) in pT1 colorectal cancers and to assess the effect of diagnostic criterion on consistency in the assessment of BLI.

METHODS

Forty consecutive patients undergoing surgical resection of pT1 colorectal cancers were entered into this study. H&E-stained, D2-40-stained and elastica-stained slides from the tumours were examined by 18 pathologists from seven countries. The 40 cases were divided into two cohorts with 20 cases each. In cohort 1, pathologists diagnosed BLI using criteria familiar to them; all Japanese pathologists used a criterion of BLI from the Japanese Society for Cancer of the Colon and Rectum (JSCCR). In cohort 2, all pathologists used the JSCCR diagnostic criterion.

RESULTS

In cohort 1, diagnostic concordance was moderate in the US/Canadian and European pathologists. There were no differences in the consistency compared with results for Japanese pathologists, and no improvement in the diagnostic concordance was found for using the JSCCR criterion. However, in cohort 2, the JSCCR criterion decreased the consistency of BLI diagnosis in the US/Canadian and European pathologists. The level of decreased consistency in the assessment of BLI was different between the US/Canadian and European pathologists.

CONCLUSIONS

A uniform criterion strongly influences the diagnostic consistency of BLI but may not always improve the concordance. Further study is required to achieve an objective diagnosis of BLI in colorectal cancer. The varying effects of diagnostic criterion on the pathologists from Japan, the USA/Canada and Europe might reflect varied interpretations of the criterion. Internationally accepted criterion should be developed by participants from around the world.

Interest & Impact

Downloads

1 since deposited on 14 Jul 2015
0 in the past 12 months

Citations

5 Citations in Web of Science ®
6 Citations in Scopus

Search

in Google Scholar™

Services

Actions (login required)

Edit item

Actions (login required)

Edit item