Making Reflective Equilibrium Precise. A Formal Model

Beisbart, Claus; Betz, Gregor; Brun, Georg (2021). Making Reflective Equilibrium Precise. A Formal Model. Ergo : an open access journal of philosophy, 8(15), pp. 441-472. University of Michigan Library 10.3998/ergo.1152

Preview

Text ergo-1152-beisbart.pdf - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons: Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works (CC-BY-NC-ND). Download (1MB) | Preview

Reflective equilibrium (RE) is often regarded as a powerful method in ethics, logic,
and even philosophy in general. Despite this popularity, characterizations of the
method have been fairly vague and unspecific so far. It thus may be doubted whether
RE is more than a jumble of appealing but ultimately sketchy ideas that cannot be
spelled out consistently. In this paper, we dispel such doubts by devising a formal
model of RE. The model contains as components the agent’s commitments and a
theory that tries to systematize the commitments. It yields a precise picture of how
the commitments and the theory are adjusted to each other. The model differentiates
between equilibrium as a target state and the dynamic equilibration process. First
solutions to the model, obtained by computer simulation, show that the method
allows for consistent specification and that the model’s implications are plausible in
view of expectations on RE. In particular, the mutual adjustment of commitments
and theory can improve one’s commitments, as proponents of RE have suggested.
We argue that our model is fruitful not only because it points to issues that need
to be dealt with for a better understanding of RE, but also because it provides the
means to address these issues.

Interest & Impact

Downloads

118 since deposited on 05 Jan 2022
65 in the past 12 months

Citations

5 Citations in Web of Science ®
6 Citations in Scopus

Search

in Google Scholar™

Services

Actions (login required)

Edit item

Actions (login required)

Edit item